1970s, 3/4, Comedy, Documentary, Fellini, Review

I Clowns

I Clowns by Nino Rota - Amazon.com Music

#15 in my ranking of Federico Fellini’s films.

I was going to skip this one in my survey of Fellini films, seeing it listed as a TV Documentary on the IMDb (it did get a limited cinema release in Italy immediately after its television debut), but then I read the littlest bit about it and realized that I needed to watch it. It fit far too well into Fellini’s thematic wheelhouse and sounded like it carried some of his later stylistic choices in their earliest phase (notably including himself as a sort of character). So, after some searching, I did find a copy with English subtitles, and I’m actually quite glad that I watched it. It’s far from one of his best works, but it’s warmly endearing towards its subject and carries the same kind of infectious energy that the best of Fellini’s later works were filled with so easily.

It’s called the first mockumentary, but I Clowns (pronounced like the English E, not the English I) exists somewhere in between genres and never really rests comfortably in one or another, much like Fellini’s imagination seemed to operate. It is uninterested in being a straight narrative, a documentary, or even a purely surrealistic expression. Instead it exists in all three realms at once with Fellini spinning them like plates in a circus act.

So, the story that is there is that the character of Fellini (played by himself) is interviewing retired circus clowns to record some kind of oral history of the dying art form, but the movie actually begins with a staged sequence of Fellini as a child watching a circus tent rise from his bedroom window. He sees the show and cries out of fear when the clowns come to the ring and perform their feats. This is the only time that Fellini explicitly relates a personal emotion towards clowns, fear, but here he is as an adult making a movie about them and their history. The movie gets peppered with similar dramatic moments full of Fellini’s familiar handling of camera, costuming, and performance as he recounts people from his old town of Remini that he considers to be clowns, or dramatizing stories from clowns about the past.

What ties them together is Fellini going around Europe with his crew, his script girl summarizing things directly into the camera while taking direction from Fellini himself, as they find the retired clowns of famous European circuses. Now, this is the part of the film that feels the most “real”, but I’m never quite willing to believe that any of it is actually real, that the people he’s interviewing were ever clowns at all. That blurring of the lines between reality and cinema seems to be the point, which is an interesting development for a director whose previous few movies have embraced theatrical affectation over strict reality. In these interviews, we receive a brief lesson on the tradition of specific clown acts with a lot of name dropping about this performer did it this way and that performer did it that way.

The movie’s final major section shows a clown funeral done in the large center ring with a bevy of clowns performing their stage-managed bouts of sadness in extended detail. This is like the centerpiece of an actual clown act in a real circus, and it ends up feeling like an elegy for a bygone era. There had been talk and heavy implication of the idea that clowning was a dying form from the interviewees, and here we get a funeral for a specific clown done by clowns themselves. The act is an extravagant one that includes men dressed as horses, a large carriage, a sock gag on the corpse’s foot, and a lot of chaos including cannons. It’s to note that Fellini is in this scene and he just quietly sits behind the camera giving the very occasional direction, but I have to imagine that he was, in every shot he did not appear, giddy with joy as he watched the chaos unfold. The tender affection for the form and those who performed it is tangible and it all unfolds in signature Fellini style.

I do find the overall picture entertaining, but I do wonder what a more straightforward take on the history of clowning might show. As it stands, I can’t believe any of the history told, feeling like the “narrator” is completely unreliable and that the whole show is a form of clowning with the audience as the joke. Still, if I’m to be the butt of this little joke, I’m okay with it. At least I laughed along the way.

Rating: 3/4

6 thoughts on “I Clowns”

  1. I saw this one in film class. I remember the teacher asking the students “Do you know what the meaning of the film is?” And he pointed out that when Fellini was asked that question, a bucket fell on his head (and the questioner’s).

    Like

    1. Fellini never took himself too seriously, and that’s one of the charms of the guy.

      I think one misconception people have about him is that he views all of his terrible main characters as heroes because they’re all, to one degree or another, based on himself, and they’re supposed to be pitied at best, not celebrated.

      The bit in I Clowns was the more comedic form of that self-reflection, I think. “It’s just a clown routine. Have fun.”

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s