1950s, 2.5/4, Comedy, John Ford, Review

The Rising of the Moon

The Rising of the Moon (1957) - IMDb

#49 in my ranking of John Ford’s filmography.

A trio of short films about Ireland, introduced by Irish-American actor Tyrone Power, The Rising of the Moon can best be described as nice. Based on three works of Irish fiction and theater written by Frank O’Connor, Martin McHugh, and Lady Gregory, while taking its title from the original title of the third work, it’s a trilogy of pastiches that try to paint the Irish character that John Ford loved. It doesn’t never gets the depth of feeling or sheer entertainment value as Ford’s The Quiet Man, but it’s never really boring. It’s just, well, it’s nice.

The first is titled “The Majesty of the Law” based on the short story by O’Connor. It’s about a police inspector, Dillon (Cyril Cusack), who decides to walk home from the constabulary in order to make a stop over at the house of Dan O’Flaherty (Noel Purcell) for what seems like a visit. Along the way, he meets the local moonshiner Mickey (Jack MacGowran), chastises him for what he’s obviously doing, and goes into the hut where Dan lives. Dan had assaulted a fellow villager, and Dillon is there to arrest him. It’s a small town environment where a local policeman knows everyone involved in a crime, and there’s a deep personal history between everyone. A conversation strikes up between the three that seems to be about the nature of the Irish character, the underlying niceness and fraternity across the small town communities along with the amusing contrast of antagonism that’s never all that dangerous. There’s the ironic ending where the man Dan had attacked tries to pay his fine for him, but Dan will not accept it from the likes of such a man and proudly delivers himself to the jail for his sentence, since he refuses to pay the fine himself.

The second story is the most amusing of the three, and the best of them. Titled “A Minute’s Wait” based on the one-act comedy by McHugh, it’s the story of a train stopped at a sleepy little station that keeps getting delayed from its one minute stop by different, very Irish, things while very Irish goings on happen at the same time. There are the older acquaintances who play matchmakers for the son and niece they represent. There’s the engineer who has a story about a ghost in a castle that the mousy woman who works behind the counter gets caught up in. There’s an older English couple on their way to a wedding who watch it all, flabbergasted, and end up getting left behind on accident. There’s the local cricket team that comes marching down the tracks and the train picks up. It’s really just a collection of moments, but they’re fun moments, building off of a little event portrayed in The Quiet Man of trains running late because train personnel have to hash out centuries’ old arguments during stops.

The final story is titled “1921” and based on the play “The Rising of the Moon” by Lady Gregory. It tells the story of an IRA member, Sean Curran (Donal Donnelly) who is about to be hung by the English military. His fate has become a cause celebre for the Irish people as a large mass of them parade in front of the jail. A pair of nuns arrive at the jail, one of them, Sister Mary Grace (Maureen Cusack), who is Curran’s sister. It’s a ruse, though, and the girl, an American with an American passport, trades places with Curran and allows him to escape. He still has to get out of militarized Dublin, though, and he takes on the disguise of a ballad singer. Whenever an Irishman recognizes him for who he is, the other immediately takes up Curran’s cover story and helps him along, eventually escaping after nearly coming to trouble under the watch of Sergeant O’Hara (Denis O’Dea) who only realizes who Curran is when he’s gotten away.

The first and third are nice little stories, but it’s the second that just goes for straight up entertaining and succeeds the most fully. The second isn’t a great piece of short film, though. It’s good.

The actors seem to be, except for Tyrone Power who only introduces the segments, Irish stage and screen actors living in Ireland, providing a very nice level of authenticity to the action.

Ford manages the interesting production well, but the depth is never there and the entertainment value somewhat limited. It’s nice.

The Majesty of the Law: 2.5/4

A Minute’s Wait: 3/4

1921: 2.5/4

Overall Rating: 2.5/4

6 thoughts on “The Rising of the Moon”

  1. I’d say that for anybody who loves The Quiet Man, this is must-see stuff. At times, with its grainy black-and-white and poor recorded sound, it feels like outtakes from TQM. Especially with so many of the Irish cast having also appeared in the previous picture, five years earlier.

    Like

  2. Man, John Ford had the biggest Ireland fetish since Cromwell.

    I’ll put this down as a ‘maybe’. I have very, very mixed feelings about IRA members and a segment where one escapes doesn’t sound like my jam.

    Like

    1. Though he was born in Maine, he was of Irish descent and loved it. It started, cinematically, as a general immigrant thing (stories of Bavarians in Four Sons, for instance, fit in with stuff like The Shamrock Handicap) with a main focus on Ireland, but as he gained power in Hollywood it focused more and more on Ireland exclusively. The Plough and the Stars was a major passion project that he ended up hating because of studio interference, for instance.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s